New Food Showdown
We are waiting on state and county guidelines as to what the 2021 Fair may look like. Stay tuned.
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Youtube Instagram Blog

Sign up for email updates from Erie County Agricultural Society

Home > Food & Drink > New Food Showdown

New Food Showdown

Check back to see who will be competing in the
2021 New Food Showdown

Voted by YOU in the Fairgrounds App


Mac & Cheese Sundae
by Mineo & Sapio


Not Your Mother's Peanut Butter & Jelly Cheesecake
by Cheesecake Guy


Lemony Fresh Bites
by Cheesecake Guy

Photo of Bacon Cheeseburger Poutine
Bacon Cheeseburger Poutine
A new take on a Northern treat! Fresh french fries covered in a brown Canadian gravy and melty cheese curds, topped with bacon and ground beef.

Poutine Gourmet

Photo of Brisket Nachos
Brisket Nachos
Dre's famous brisket chopped and served on nachos chips, with cheese and a signature sauce drizzled on top (spice it up with jalapeno peppers).

Dre's Place BBQ
Photo of Buffalo Chicken Banana Peppers
Buffalo Chicken Banana Peppers
A Buffalo match made in heaven! Banana pepper stuffed with buffalo style chicken filling.

Salvatore's Pizza
Photo of Chicken Feta Fries
Chicken Feta Fries
Marinated chicken breast on top of a bed of steak cut fries, topped with feta cheese, garlic sauce, and Greek dressing.
Photo of Hot Candy Wings
Hot Candy Wings
Buffalo chicken wings that are prepared in a favorite fair style that you will love. These chicken wings are topped off with a hot candy sauce, which is the flavor of a warm spicy candy apple.

Photo of Mac & Cheese Sundae
Mac & Cheese Sundae
Who says you can’t have a sundae for dinner? Elbow macaroni smothered in a four cheese sauce with red and green peppers, caramelized onions, sausage “sprinkles,” topped with traditional red sauce and a meatball “cherry” on top.

Mineo & Sapio
Photo of Pierogi Poutine with Shreded Pot Roast
Pierogi Poutine with Shredded Pot Roast
Babcia’s potato cheddar pierogi topped with cheese curds, shredded Guinness pot roast and savory gravy to make the ultimate poutine.

Babcia's Pierogi

Photo of Potato Butts
Potato Butts
Deep fried potato slices garnished with your choice of cheese and bacon, sour cream and chive, or hot sauce.

Renaissance Lodge Curly Q's

Photo of Soba Noodle Stir-Fry
Soba Noodle Stir-Fry with Sweet Teriyaki Chicken
Wok-fried soba noodles with market fresh vegetables glazed in a signature sweet teriyaki sauce, and served with sweet teriyaki chicken.

Wok on the Wild Side Foods

Photo of Flamin Hot Cheetos Fries
The Flaming Hot Cheetos Fries
Hot, freshly made fries drizzled with cheddar cheese sauce and finished with Flaming Hot Cheetos to bring some heat to this original treat.

Big Kahuna's

Sweets & Treats

Photo of Caramel Crack Fries
Caramel Crack Fries
Crispy fries covered with salted caramel and rolled cinnamon sugar, with whipped cream and fruity pebbles on top to complete this treat.

Big Kahuna's
Photo of Mini Pancakes
Luv Puffs, AKA "Poffertjets"
A popular festival and street market dessert originating in Amsterdam. This treat resembles mini, fluffy pancakes. The batter is made fresh each day! Pancakes served with gourmet toppings like Nutella Crunch.

Tropic Love
Photo of Loganberry Corndog
Loganberry Funnel Cake Corndog
A hot dog dipped in funnel cake batter, deep fried to perfection, drizzled with loganberry syrup and a dash of powdered sugar. Breakfast, lunch, dinner, dessert all in one!

Chester's Gators & Taters
Photo of PB&J Cheesecake
Not Your Mother's Peanut Butter and Jelly Cheesecake
This is not your mother’s PB&J, but she’ll definitely want to try some! Two slices of peanut butter cheesecake sandwiched around a layer of loganberry jelly with a drizzle of peanut butter, more delicious jelly and a side of potato chips.

Cheesecake Guy
Photo of Strawberry Mezza Luna
Strawberry Mezza Luna (Strawberry and Cream Cheese Filled Calzone)
A classic calzone crust filled with strawberries and cream cheese… a sweet treat sure to please!

Salvatore's Pizza

Healthy Options

Photo of Fair logo
Avocado Double Chocolate Cookies

All About the Sugar
Photo of Lemony Fresh Bites
Lemony Fresh Bites

Cheesecake Guy
Sparkling Water Float

GLO Concessions
Photo of fair logo
Shrimp, Broccoli, and Rice

Eastern Pearl Restaurant

2018 New Food Showdown Winner

Photo of the New Food Showdown Winner 2018
2018 New Food Showdown Winner
Apple Quesadilla by Jack's Delicious Taco in a Bag

Back to