New Food Showdown
Find My Order
Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram Blog TikTok

Sign up for email updates from Erie County Fair

Home > Food & Shopping > New Food Showdown

New Food Showdown

Best Savory

Fly with the Bills Baked Potato by Carolina Pork BBQ Baked Potato
Located on Trackside

Best Sweet & Treat

Chocolate Tap by Chocolate Tap
Located on Trackside

Best Beverage

Fruity Pebbles Shake by Ice Cream Shoppe
Located on the Strates Shows Midway


New Food Showdown Location Map

2025 New Food Showdown Contestants


Savory


New York Style Gyro
New York Style Gyro
Authentic Greek Foods
Located on Broadway & Trackside

Hand-stacked layers of Mediterranean marinated meat slow roasted and served in a soft pita and topped with fresh vegetables.


philly cheesesteak pierogi
Philly Cheesesteak Pierogi
Babcia's Pierogi
Located on Broadway

Pierogi filled with shaved steak, caramelized peppers and onion, mushrooms and provolone cheese and topped with caramelized peppers and onions, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese.


mexican street corn baked potato
Mexican Street Corn Potato
Spud-tastic Potato
Located on 42nd Street

A baked potato topped with butter, Mexican sweet corn, cilantro and garnished with a lime.

chicken mac and cheese
Boom Boom Chicken Mac
Brody's Mac & Cheese
Located 42nd Street

Creamy mac and cheese topped with crispy chicken bites then drizzled with zesty boom boom sauce for the perfect kick.


hogfries
Hogfries
Brody's BBQ
Located on 42nd Street

Fresh-cut fries topped with nacho cheese, Brody’s wood fired pulled pork and finished off with Brody’s signature BBQ sauce.


Pineapple Pork Sandwich
Pineapple Pork Sandwich
Brazilian Bowls
Located on Broadway

Tender, slow-roasted pork piled high and topped with vibrant, garlicky chimichurri sauce on a toasted bun.

flaming hot fries
Flaming Hot Fries
Millennium Chips
Located Avenue of Flags

French fries topped with melted cheese, crushed flaming hot Cheetos and fresh jalapenos.


belly melon taco
Belly Melon Taco
BoBo's Taco Box
Located on Trackside

Balsamic glazed pork belly topped with diced watermelon, onion, cilantro, cotija cheese, and crema.


dill corn cob
Dilly Cob
The Crafted Cob
Located behind the Grandstand

Corn on the cob coated in a dill sauce and topped with fresh-chopped dill pickle.


Chicken Taco in a bag
The Tailgater
Josh's Delicious Tacos
Located on Broadway

Buffalo sauced chicken topped with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and blue cheese. Served in a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos.


chicken wing baked potato
Fly with the Bills Baked Potato
Carolina Pork BBQ Baked Potato
Located on Trackside

Chicken wing baked potato made with shredded cheese, hot sauce, and blue cheese. Garnished with celery sticks.


detroit style pizza
Pizza Amore Detroit Style Pizza
Pizza Amore "The Detroit Way"
Located on Avenue of Flags

A Detroit style dough topped with fresh sauce, Wisconsin brick cheese, mozzarella, whipped ricotta and basil.


buffalo meatballs
Buffalo Meatballs
Sal's Pasta Shoppe
Located on 42nd Street

Italian meatballs tossed in tangy house made buffalo sauce, served with celery and blue cheese dressing.


pizza bomb
Pizza Bomb
Salvatore's Pizza
Located on 42nd Street

Fresh made pizza dough rolled around melty cheese, pepperoni and signature pizza sauce, baked to perfection.


waffle grilled cheese
Waffle Grilled Cheese
The Big Cheese
Located behind the Grandstand

Crispy waffles sandwich melty cheese and smoky bacon, finished with a drizzle of rich maple syrup.


pesto gnocchi
Pistachio Pesto Perfection
The Gnocchi Co.
Located behind the Grandstand

Homemade gnocchi tossed in rich, nutty pistachio pesto.


loaded corn-waffle dog
Loaded Corn-Waffle Dog
Waffle Wagon
Located on 42nd Street

A Sahlen’s hot dog cooked in corn-waffle batter, topped with nacho cheese, crispy onions, potato sticks, and Hot Cheeto dust.


Papa Loca
Taqueria Illegal
Located on the Strates Shows Midway

Baked potato with carne asada, al pastor, or Pollo Asado, served with butter, onions, nacho cheese, cilantro, and sour cream.


Flaming Hot Cheetos Blooming Onion
Korean Corn Dogs
Located on the Strates Shows Midway

Fresh onion, battered and fried, topped with melted cheddar cheese and a sprinkle of Flaming Hot Cheetos crumbs.


Loaded Bison Pickle Chips
716 Loaded Bison Pickle Chips
Chester's Gators & Taters
Located on Broadway & Trackside

Crispy fried pickle chips topped with Bison French Onion Dip and chopped candied bacon pieces.


Sweets & Treats

chocolate chip-brownie bomb
Chocolate Chip-Brownie Bomb
The Cookie Barn
Located on Slade Park

Gooey chocolate brownie wrapped in a chocolate chip cookie.


lime margarita pierogi
Lime Margarita Cheesecake Pierogi
Babcia's Pierogi
Located on Broadway

Lime margarita cheesecake filled pierogi, encrusted with graham cracker crumbs. Topped with raspberry sherbert and drizzled with raspberry and chocolate sauce.


Sundae in a Chips Ahoy bag
Sundae in a Bag
The Original Barbie's Ice Cream Shoppe
Located 42nd Street

Chips Ahoy cookies topped with twist ice cream, chocolate syrup, whipped cream and a cherry. Finished off with crumbled cookies.


chocolate strawberries
Chocolate Tap
Chocolate Tap
Located on Trackside

Fresh strawberries smothered in silky smooth chocolate.


cinnamon sugar pretzel bites
Cinnamon Sugar Bites
Pretzelo
Located behind the Grandstand

Cinnamon sugar pretzalo bites topped with a frosting drizzle.


hawaiian crumble sundae
Hawaiian Crumble Sundae
Dippin Dots
Located on Avenue of Flags

A tropical escape with pineapple and coconut ice cream topped with lime syrup, cake crumbles and toasted coconut flakes.


apple fritters
Apple Fritters
Piccolo's Sugar Waffles
Located on Broadway

Delicious tender golden donuts with freshly diced Honeycrisp apples.


cookie butter frozen cheesecake
Cookie Butter Frozen Cheesecake
Polar Bear Concessions
Located on 42nd Street

Famous frozen cheesecake dipped in a homemade cookie butter shell then rolled in crushed Biscoff cookies.

Cookie Butter Sandwich
Cookie Butter Sandwich Extravaganza
Polar Bear Homemade Ice Cream
Located on Avenue of Flags

Vanilla bean ice cream with cookie butter, chocolate chunks, and Biscoff crumbles, sandwiched between chocolate chip cookies, dipped in chocolate, and rolled in more Biscoff.

fried cinnamon sugar gnocchi
Cinnamon Sugar Pillows
The Gnocchi Co.
Located behind the Grandstand

Homemade fried gnocchi sprinkled with cinnamon sugar.


waffle on a stick
Snack Attack
Waffle Wagon
Located on 42nd Street

Belgian waffle on a stick, dipped in milk chocolate and topped with Heath toffee, pretzels, potato sticks, and a white and milk chocolate drizzle.

Beverages

dirty soda
Dirty Soda
Grandma Rose's Birch Beer Emporium
Located 42nd Street & Trackside

Soda with an infusion of cream and a hint of coconut and citrus flavor.


chocolate chip cold brew latte
Chocolate Chip Cold Brew Latte
The Cookie Barn
Located on Slade Park

Cold brew latte flavored with chocolate chip cookie flavoring topped with sweet vanilla cold foam and a chocolate chip cookie.


Fruity Pebbles Shake
Ice Cream Shoppe
Located on the Strates Shows Midway

Gourmet milkshake coated in crunchy cereal and cherry syrup, crowned with two chocolate covered strawberries.


layered smoothie
Buffalo Smoothie
Jungle Juice Smoothies
Located on 42nd Street, Trackside & top of the Avenue of Flags

Layered smoothie with strawberry, lemonade, and blue raspberry flavors.

watermelon jalapeno refresher
Watermelon Jalapeño Refresher
BoBo's Taco Box
Located on Trackside

Watermelon margarita mocktail infused with fresh jalapeño.


Dr. Pepper and Pickles
Dr. Pepper & Pickles
Korean Corn Dogs
Located on the Strates Shows Midway

A cup of Dr. Pepper served with a pile of dill pickles on top.


Back to
Top
Tickets